MIGRATION OF ALLUVIAL GOLD
By F. Lynwood Garrison, M.I.M.M.
RENEWED interest has been aroused in some of the old but
rather obscure
questions relating to the distribution and
concentration of gold in
streams draining areas known to
be auriferous. Gold has been generally considered to be soluble
only with great difficulty in natural solvents, but its solution
and transport under natural conditions now existing are
beginning to be more generally recognised. It is well known
that gold is slightly affected by alkaline solutions as well as
by some nitrates and that from such solutions it may be preci-
pitated by organic matter derived from vegetation. In fact it
is soluble in meteoric waters and it is felt that this action has
played an important part in the migration, dispersion and
concentration of the metal in alluvials.
It has been generally observed that the purity
of alluvial
gold in many instances is greater than that of the lode gold of
the districts eroded. This is explained by the fact that silver
- the almost invariable associate of lode or hypogene gold- is
more readily soluble in natural waters than gold. This observa-
tion fails to some extent to account for the homogeneity of some
of the gold nuggets that have been examined by sectioning.
In the ordinary methods of fire-assay parting, it is well known
that if the silver in the bullion button, or
"prill" is less than
two-thirds of the whole only the outside of the button will
be
attacked by the parting solvent and it would seem from this
that the solution of the silver in the alluvial gold is never
complete.
This accounts for the varying fineness of the metal from different
spots or localities often in the same stream-bed or section of the
alluvial deposit, although the original lode gold,usually carries
fluctuating amounts of silver which may result in the gold vary-
ing within wide limits of fineness.
According to Ross
E. Brown' the results from 800 placer
mines and 200 quartz claims in the principal mining districts of
west flank of the Sierra Nevada in California was as
follows:-
Range of fineness. Placers. Quartz.
% %
Less than
0.700
1 8
0.700. to
0.800
4 14
0.800 to
0.900
50 65
More than
0.900 45
13
The: average fineness from 800 placers was 0. 800 and the average
from 200 quartz deposits 0.820. In all of
the 1,000 locations it
0.876. Ross states further that in Placer County,
California,
it was found that 85 per cent. of the
placer or alluvial
gold would pass through a ten-mesh
sieve and less than one-half
of 1 per,eent. through a 40-mesh sieve, so that the average size
of the grains was between ten and forty-mesh.
Tests made by the Geological Survey
of Canada on a series
of selected nuggets showed that their surface assayed higher in
gold than the interior. It seems certain
the variations in the
fineness of placer gold depends largely on the original
differences
in the amount of silver of the lode gold from which the
alluvial
gold was derived. In ores or lode-gold deposits of
lower grade
the silver is sometimes nearly equal in amount to that of the
gold, the ratio being about 1:1.4, whereas in high-grade ores it
may be 1:5, and a general average of probably 1:2.3 may,
perhaps, be taken. In value the ratio of silver to the gold
obviously depends upon the market price of the former and is
relatively small, being approximately, something like 1:150 or
1:200. (In 1999 more like 1:50.)
According to Maclaren the purity of alluvial gold is gene-
rally in inverse proportion to the size of the grain; in other
words the small grains or "colours" are richer than the larger,
which is explained by the fact that the smaller particles of gold
present a relatively larger surface to the agents of solution and
may have travelled farther from their source. Maclaren also
states that the largest and purest samples of amorphous, mam-
millary, and crystalline gold have been obtained from alluvials.
The logical conclusion is that gold in alluvials is enriched by the
solution or removal of a part of the silver or added to by the
precipitation of soluble gold in ionized waters circulating through
the sands and gravels of such detritus. Probably either or both
reactions increase the fineness of the gold. Although gold
is
soluble in certain combinations of inorganic salts and acids
as
well as in some organic acids derived from vegetation,
the
potency of the latter agent as an important factor in the
trans-
port and enrichment of alluvial gold appears not to have
been
recognised sufficiently.
As is probably well
known
Dr. Thomas Egleston, of the Columbia School of Mines,
New
York, carried on an incomplete series of experiments some years
ago (1879) to determine the solubility of gold in natural waters
under various conditions assumed to be comparable to conditions
existing in nature. His results appear to have justified the
conclusion that solution and reprecipitation take place under
favourable conditions. The postulate of solution in this way may
be admitted, but just how the precipitation is effected is not so
clear; probably it is brought about by several different and com-
plex agencies. Manganese oxides are frequently present in
alluvial gravels, especially in older more or less consolidated
deposits, and in the absence of alkaline solutions such manganese
salts interact with chlorides liberating chlorine- a very active
solvent of gold. Reducing and precipitating agents for gold in
nature are numerous. Organic matter of almost any kind is
rarely or never absent from soils, so that gold in solution is
unlikely to be carried long distances through such alluvials
without being precipitated, provided the circulation of the
aqueous solutions is slow and sluggish.
Years ago the writer was impressed by personal
observations
and experience in the tropics with the force of some of these
conclusions and discussed the subject at length. It was not,
however, until he had the opportunity of reading Harrison's
report on the goldfields of British Guiana that he became
impressed with the soundness of this theory. Harrison drew
upon a number of observations and tests made both by himself
and others and showed that in one instance the ashes of certain
trees grown on auriferous laterite of the Omai district contained
from 2 to 10 grains of gold per ton and that the ash from
the
upper part of the tree trunks, near the branches, yielded as
much
as 28 grains per ton. It was also observed that the ash of the
bark contained only 1 grain per ton, whereas the wood itself
produced from 7 to 10 grains. Gold was also found on
the
steel valves of the pumps used in washing this laterite,
but
Harrison thought it not unlikely that this gold may have been
in suspension in the water. It was not possible,
however,for
gold in that state to have obtained access to the wood of the
the interior of the tree. It might be mentioned in this
connection
that Liversidge found as much as 22 grains per ton of gold in
the ashes of sea kelp.
It has been frequently noticed that old tailings from
mine
and mill dumps, especially when overgrown with vegetation,
show evidences of secondary or renewed enrichment due
sup-
posedly to underground transport, solution, and reprecipitation
of gold. It has also been observed that rocks and soils relatively
free from carbonates acquire gold more readily than others,
owing, presumably, to the neutralisation of the humic acids by
carbonates.
As the result of laboratory experiments some
investigators
have discussed the probable effect of colloidal enrichment and
deposition, but, as pointed out by Blanchard, colloidal
solutions
of gold are very unstable and it seems unlikely that they
are
present in ore deposits in sufficient concentration to be of
much
importance as a factor in the deposition of gold.
Blanchard
further observes that in the New Guinea gold deposits
the
enrichment appears to be greatest in the highly
manganiferous
portions, close to air exposures, and present in less than
normal
amount in similar but highly limonitic situations. Certainly
nascent chlorine in mangniferous ground-water will dissolve
gold, while ferrous sulphate is an active precipitant of that
metal. Since manganese oxide will reduce ferric sulphate to
ferrous, it follows that gold may be dissolved and reprecipitated
in alluvial areas that are strongly manganese-stained and
through which water circulates freely. Bastin has shown that
a gold sol may develop by the action of sulphides on gold chloride
solutions.
According to Boydell the presence
of small amounts of
gold is not uncommon in limonitic and manganiferous deposits
its presence being consistent both with the
well-recognised
adsorptive powers of both these substances and with the adsorp-
tion consequent on the colloidal development of surface. He
says-
The
grinding and comminution resulting from the
erosion of outcropping lodes must
produce particles cap-
able of colloidal
dispersion.... Coagulation of extremely
dilute sols, thus produced, in
locations where stagnant
conditions prevail, would account
for the "flour gold"
common in many placers. Growth of
the larger of
these
particles at the expense of the
smaller would lead either
to the formation of nuggets or to
the continued growth
of pre-existing ones.
Nugget growth after this manner
could, of course, only take place
under favourable condi-
tions - i.e., in stagnant or
semi-stagnant waters.
W. H. Emmons refers to the paucity of
experimental data
relating to the solubility of gold under conditions of weathering.
He mentions those obtained by Freise, which are discussed later
in this article, and refers to the fact that statements of much
gold being dissolved and reprecipitated in placers have frequently
been made, but have not been generally accepted, in North
America.
F. L. Ress refers to the gold
deposited in the
sedimentaries
near the Homestead lode as coming from that source and as
containing less silver than the lode ore itself, "as might be
expected in a placer derived from it."
While it is generally
conceded that placer gold is purer than
lode gold - i.e., less argentiferous - the rule has exceptions. Thus
Rose states that this is not the case in the Ural districts of
Russia, where the relative amounts of gold and silver are quite
variable both in the placers and in the lode ores. This is pro-
bably the general experience everywhere, but there can be no
question that in travelling or migrating from the original lode
to the detrital the gold is purified by the removal of part of its
original silver.
Although organic matter and
organic acids are regarded as
precipitants of gold, others are known to be solvents. Gold may
also be thrown out of solution by many sulphides, especially
pyrite and galena. According to Skeyl one part of pyrite will
precipitate eight parts of gold. It would seem that although the
natural solvents of gold are rather numerous it is also true it
cannot be carried far where there is an abundance of organic
matter. It has been recorded by Freise that in Brazil the
lower portions of old placers (old in the sense of having once
been supposedly exhausted) have been profitably reworked after
years under conditions that precluded mechanical enrichment.
There seems to be no doubt that under the conditions described
by Freise gold was transported from one part of a mineral
deposit, to another and redeposited. Freise further remarks-
All
milling companies or individual miners who have
worked alluvial deposits in Brazil
realise that gold placers
once supposed thoroughly
exhausted may after a period
of years once more be panned and yield a
profitable
amount of newly-accumalated gold. The
native gold
digger maintains that every gold
placer within ten years
is rich enough to be worked once more and
that.payable
gold reappears the sooner if the
exhausted gold field has
been hidden from the sun by vegetation or
other means.
In such instances it is affirmed that new
gold is quite
different from the original gold in colour, coarseness, and affinity
to mercury.
The role of the so-called flood-gold in the enrichment of
placers is an important, but also a somewhat difficult, factor to
evaluate in considering the origin and growth of the
gold
particles in such alluvials. By the term flood-gold is meant the
gold which is deposited during flood periods on the sand and
gravel bars of the curves and eddies in large streams. Accord-
ing to Purington such gold usually accumulates at points from
30 to 70 miles from the original source. It is important to bear
this fact in mind when testing, plotting, and evaluating gold-
bearing alluvials, since flood-gold is transitory and is of little
importance when estimating the ultimate value of the deposits.
Flood-gold is mostly flaky, whereas that on bedrock is usually
granular. Between bedrock and the surface of the stream-bed
any shape and form of gold particles may be expected.
As has been pointed out by Posepny the
concentration
of gold on bedrock cannot be, assumed to be simply a settling
process on a large scale, since the metal generally shows no
sorting or classification in placers. In
addition the gravels
seldom exhibit evidence of
classification, being generally com-
posed throughout of particles varying greatly in size
and weight.
At the same time it is not safe to assume that in a
cross-section
of a stream or river valley the so-called pay-gravel and
bed-rock
are necessarily the richest part of the deposit
there is always
some horizontal variation of value and barren intervals
in
different pay-streaks. The mechanical
distribution of gold
in
alluvials is a wholly different problem- or group of
problems-
from that of the migration by solution. Obviously,
however,
they are not independent but complementary, the gold in
solut-
tion being precipitated on solid particles of gold or other
metallic
material associated mechanically with the alluvial sands
and
gravels. The mechanical dispersion and concentration of
gold
is evidently the resultant of a complex combination of
conditions
-geological, topographical, and climatic - as well as
being
affected by the character of the detrital material
itself. t
It seems more than
likely (and it is the general opinion
of those who have studied the subject) that although by far
the
larger part of detrital gold has been received directly
from the
older sources, chiefly lodes, by mechanical erosion an
appre-
ciable proportion was probably derived by precipitation
from
aqueow solutions. If the secondary or
sedimentary origin of the
Transvaal gold-bearing conglomerates be conceded, detrital
gold
deposits have always been, and doubtless will long continue
to
be, the most important source of the world's gold
supply. While
it is evident that gold is widely if sparsely
distributed through
the crystalline rocks, it is certain that its accumulation
in
metallic veins or lodes is relatively rare, especially when
of
sufficient richness to pay for mining.. There seems to be
little
doubt that the greater part of' the gold in placer or
alluvial
depbsits was derived not so much from large workable veins
or
lodes as from the innumerable small veins and quartz
stringers
which sometimes occur as a distinct feature in areas of
pre-
Cambridn rocks, as well as in some of the older sedimentary
rocks associated with igneous intrusions.
Many, possibly most,
geologists and mining engineers will
agree that the future gold supply of the world is limited,
also
that many known deposits have been greatly depleted
and some
wholly exhausted. This is true of those in the United
States
and Europe. It seems unlikely that any major deposits
com-
parable to those of South Africa will again be
discovered. With
the possible exception of Siberia there are now few areas
of the
earth's surface remaining to be explored, and with the
advent of
the aeroplane there will soon be few nooks and corners of
the
land surface which have not come under observation.
As a
by-product or associate with other metals and ores the
output of
gold is likely to continue large, but at best this quantity
is
small as compared with that of the Transvaal and the
combined
production of gold-lode mines in other parts of the
world. It
is difficult, perhaps, for the public to understand that
the once
famous alluvial gold deposits of California, Australia, and
Alaska were Nature's hoards, treasure-trove whose
gold was
eroded from neighbouring rocks within the hills and
mountains
of the district through periods of thousands of years and
concen-
trated in surface accumulations easily accessible to man's
simple
tools, chiefly the pick and shovel. These diggings, as they
were
known, became quickly exhausted.
In Roman times gold was
washed from the beds and bars
of streams of Central Europe, especially the Rhine and some
of
the smaller streams of France. With the growth of
civilisation
and increase of population these deposits were rapidly
exhausted.
Alhough contemporary replacement is a practically negligible
factor there are or have often been in relatively large
streams,
as for instance in northern California, small quantities of gold
widely spread throughout their beds which can often be
profit-
ably recovered with modern dredges. Under favourable
condi-
ions such machines or boats will handle from 100 to 200
cubic
yards of unconsolidated alluvial material per hour of
operation
and obtain a profit from ground containing as little as 4
to 5
cents of gold per cubic yards. The cost of these
operations
obviously must vary widely, depending upon a variety
of factors
or conditions which are probably seldom quite the same in any
two localities. It may be as low as 3 cents per cubic yard or as
high as 35 to 40 cents where the ground has to be thawed, as in
Alaska, the Yukon, and Siberia. On the whole this form of gold
mining has frequently proved very profitable where conditions
have been favourable. By skilful prospect-drilling, sampling,
and mapping the ore reserves, so to speak, can be established
with fair accuracy and the life and potential profits of the opera-
tion safely forecast and estimated to a degree seldom equalled
in hard rock goldmining.
The writer is well aware that the theory of gold solution
and
redeposition in alluvials has never received much support among
North American geologists and mining engineers, probably
because of the absence of tropical conditions in areas with which
they are best acquainted and a preconceived notion on their part
that such a postulate is fantastic. It might seem, however,
that there is reason to doubt the denial of the claim. It is
certain that in tropical countries, where conditions are favour-
able, there is no gainsaying that such solution, migration, and
redeposition of gold frequently does take place.
Since the foregoing was written the author's attention has
been called to the experiments of W. G. Fetzer at the University
of Minnesota relating to the transport of gold by organic solu-
tions. These investigations appear to throw some doubt upon
the results of the work carried out by Freise in Brazil. Fetzer
states-
The
reaction between humic acid and gold may be
regarded as oxidation when one considers
that a gold
atom would have to lose either one or
three valence elec-
trons in order to combine as a
humate. It is significant
that by its position in the
electro-chemical series gold
tends to retain its normal number of
electrons tenaciously.
Therefore, it is difficult to understand
this paradox that
humic acid, a reducing agent could
oxidize gold.
Discount Wines - 1500 Best Australian Wines